Alfie’s Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Alfie’s Pizza, a hidden gem located at 41 Broadway in Rocky Point, NY. This cozy Italian pizzeria is celebrated for its authentic, flavorful pizzas, homemade dough, and inviting atmosphere. Whether you choose to dine in, enjoy outdoor seating, or opt for delivery, Alfie's ensures a fantastic culinary experience.

Alfie’s menu is a delightful blend of traditional and innovative offerings. Customers rave about their grandma pizza with prosciutto, fried calamari, and generous portion sizes. The $16.99 dinner specials from Tuesday to Saturday are a fantastic deal!

  • Homemade Ingredients: Every dish features freshly made dough and bread.
  • Family-Friendly Vibes: The staff is warm and accommodating, making it a great spot for families.
  • Quality Service: Praised for quick and friendly service, Alfie's ensures a memorable visit each time.

Discover why patrons keep returning to this delightful pizzeria. At Alfie’s, delicious food and great service come together perfectly!

Pizza

Neopolitan 18 Large Round

$20.99

Neopolitan 14 Small Round

$16.99

Sicilian Pie

$21.99

Grandma Pie

$23.99

Detroit Pie

$19.99

Gluten Free Personal

$16.99

!! Gluten Free DETROIT !!

$17.99

Margherita 18

Fresh Mozz, Basil, San Marzano Plum Tomatoes

$30.99

BBQ Chicken 18

$30.99

Buffalo Chicken 18

$30.99

White 18

Ricotta and Mozz

$30.99

Hawaiian 18

Pineapple and bacon

$30.99

Margherita 14

Fresh Mozz, Basil, San Marzano Plum Tomatoes

$24.99

BBQ Chicken 14

$24.99

Buffalo Chicken 14

$24.99

White 14

$24.99

Hawaiian 14

$24.99

Salad 18

Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Olives, Dressing, on a Cheese Crust

$30.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch 18

$30.99

18 Sausage Broccoli Di Rabe

$30.99

Square Crispino Pie

$30.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch 14

$24.99

14Sausage Broccoli Di Rabe

$24.99

Calzone

$10.99

Vodka Chicken Rectangle Pie

$35.99

Vodka Sicilian Rectangle

$30.99

18 Everything Pie Roni,Sausage, Meatball, Mush, Pepper, Onion

$30.99

18 Veggie Lover Pepper, Onion, Mushroom, Rabe

$30.99

18Meat Lover Pie Roni, Sausage,Meatball, Ham

$30.99

Sicilian Marinara No Mozz Cheese

$21.99

Salad 14

$24.99

18 Chicken Parm Pie

$30.99

Stuffed Meat Pizza

$39.99

18 Eggplant Brushetta

$34.99

18 Chicken Francese Pizza

$34.99

Cheezy Bread Pie 12x17

$18.99

Sicilian Sweet Chili Chicken W Pineapple

$32.99

Loaded Potato 18

$32.99

18 Mac Daddy

$35.99

18 Taco Fiesta

$32.99

18 Deep Dish Pizza

$30.99

18 Baked Ziti

$30.99

14 Chicken Francese

$27.99

18 Chipolte Chicken

$30.99

Upside Down Sicilian

$25.99

Grandpa Sicilian W Onions Breadcrumbs

$27.99

Upside Down Vodka Sicilian

$34.99

18 Fried Calamari Pie

$39.99

18 Spicy Vodka Chicken Sesame Seed Crust

$36.99

18 Heart Shaped Vodka Ravioli Pie

$36.99

14 Heart Shaped Vodka Ravioli Pie

$30.99

18 3 Marinara Ravioli

$30.99

14 3 Marinara Ravioli

$24.99

18 Heart Pasta Vodka Pesto

$29.99

14 Heart Pasta Vodka Pesto

$25.99

12 Heart Chocolate Special

$19.99

Alfies SALAD

Romaine Lettuce Topped w Mozz w House Dressing

$13.99

Southwest Salad

Romaine Lettuce , Corn, Black Bean, Tomato, Tortilla Strips, Cheddar Blend, w Ranch Dressing

$13.99

Ceasar Salad

Romaine Lettuce, Croutons, Shredded Parmigiana, w Caesar dressing

$13.99

Greek Salad

$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$19.99

Greens

Munchies

Alfies Famous FRIES

Seasoned Fries w Crumbled Bacon and Mozzaerlla

$14.99

Wings

Traditional or Boneless

$16.99

Baked Clams

$15.99

Fried Calamari

$17.99

Fried Ravioli

Served W Marinana Sauce

$11.99

Italian Wedding Soup

$7.99

Mozz Sopresatta Roasted Peppers

$14.99

Mozzarella Sticks

Served W Marinana Sauce

$11.99

Mussels

Choice of Marinara or Garlic Oil

$15.99

Pizza Kit

$12.99

Potato, Bacon, Cheddar Soup

$7.99

French Onion Soup

$7.99

Shrimp Cocktail

$15.99

Stuffed Mushrooms

$14.99

12 Tray Wing Sunday Special

$49.99

Lobster Bisque

$14.99

Alfies Burger Fries

Beef Burger w melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle, and fries

$16.99

Alfies Veggie Burger Fries

Veggie Burger w melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle, and fries

$12.99

Chicken Fingers W French Fries

$14.99

Penne Alla Vodka

Creamy Pink Sauce w Prosciutto

$19.99

Eggplant Rollatini Penne

Eggplant in Marinara Sauce, Stuffed w Ricotta and Mozzarella Served w Penne

$18.99

Eggplant Parm Penne

Eggplant in Marinara Sauce, Covered w Mozzarella Served w Penne

$18.99

Ravioli Marinara

$13.99

Chicken Parmigiana Penne

Chicken in Marinara Sauce, Covered w Mozzarella Served w Penne

$21.99

Sausage,Peppers,Onion In A Marinana Sauce W Penne

Sausage Peppers in a Marinana Sauce, Served w Penne

$21.99

Penne W Sausage Broccoli Di Rabe, Sundried Tomato

Pasta Sauteed with Rabe, Sausage, Sundried Tomato, in Garlic Oil

$21.99

Penne Meatballs In A Marinana Sauce

$16.99

Penne Dinner With Marinara Sauce

$11.99

Baked Ziti

$16.99

Shrimp Parmigiana Penne

$25.99

Lobster Ravioli

$24.99

Linguini Clam Sauce

$20.99

Chicken Francese Penne

$25.99

Manicotti

$16.99

Stuffed Shells

$16.99

Pasta Combo

$16.99

Fettuccini Alfredo

$20.99

Lasagna

$21.99

Grilled Chicken W Side Broccoli Di Rabe

$20.99

Shrimp Francese

$26.99

Shrimp Scampi Over Spaghetti

$25.99

Penne W Broccoli Garlic Oil

$21.99

Favorites

Hero

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

$13.99

Chicken BLT Hero

$14.99

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

$13.99

Sausage Parmigana Hero

$13.99

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

$12.99

Sausage, Pep On Parm Hero

$13.99

Sausage Meatball Parm Hero

$13.99

Shrimp Parmigiana Hero

$15.99

Chicken Francese Hero

$14.99

Egg And Potato Parm Hero

$12.99

Regular Slice

$3.55

Detroit Slice

$4.99

Sicilian Slice

$3.85

White Slice

$4.50

Grandma Slice

$4.00

Margherita Slice

$4.50

Buffalo Chicken Slice

$5.50

Quick Premium Sicilian

$5.50

Hot Pepp Detroit Slice

$5.75

Chicken Parm Slice

$5.50

Premium Detroit Slice

$5.99

BBQ Chicken Slice

$5.50

Garlic Knot Premium

$5.50

Garlic Knot Slice

$4.00

Vodka Detroit Slice

$5.99

Premium Slice

$5.50

Eggplant Crispino Slice

$6.25

Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

$5.50

Upside Down Sicilian Slice

$4.00

Salad Slice W Chicken

$6.95

Meat Lover Sicilian

$5.50

VEGGIE Sicilian

$5.50

Deep Dish Slice

$5.50

Chipolte Chicken Slice

$5.50

Sweet Chili Chicken

$5.50

Grandpa Detroit Slice

$5.75

Regular Slice Roni Bacon

$5.75

Upside Doewn Vodka Slice

$5.50

Grandpa Sicilian

$5.50

MVP Detroit Slice

$5.99

Fried Calamari Slice

$7.95

Arugula Slice

$5.50

Mango Arugula CHICKEN Slice

$6.95

Deep Dish Veggie Slice

$5.75

Burratta Grandma Slice

$4.95

Feta Slice

$5.50

Shrimp Sampi Slice

$6.99

Buns

$2.25

Taco Slice

$6.95

Grandma W Roni Pesto

$5.50

Wildfire Relief Slice

$5.50

Spicy Chicken Vodka

$5.75

Fried Shrimp Slice

$6.99

Plain Shell No Sauce No Added Cheese Add Eggplant Mozz Roasted Peppper

$6.50

Pizza By The Slice

Extras

Single Garlic Knot

$0.75

12 Doz Garlic Knots

$3.50

1 Dozen Knots

$7.00

12oz Bottle Hot Honey

$13.99

Broccoli Di Rabe

Sauteed in Garlic Oil

$11.99

Fries

$6.99

Garlic Bread

$5.99

Hot Honey Cup

$2.00

Pizza Dough

$5.99

Side Blue Cheese

$1.00

Side Of Meatballs

2 Meatballs in Sauce

$8.99

Side Of Penne W Marinara Sauce

$7.99

Side Of Sausage

2 Sausage in Sauce

$8.99

Side Ranch

$1.00

Side Of Grated Cheese

$1.00

Side Of Ricotta

$1.99

Side Of Buffalo Sauce

$1.00

Side Grilled Chicken 2

$7.99

Cake

$6.99

3oz Sauce

$1.00

8oz Sauce Half Pint

$2.99

8 Oz Half Pint Vodka Sauce

$5.99

Side Fried Chicken 2

$7.99

Drizzle Hot Honey On Slice

$0.50

Drizzle Hot Honey On Pie

$1.50

Side Of Italian Dressing

$1.00

Pizzelle Waffle Cookie

$6.99

Side Of Anchovies 4 Pieces

$3.00

3 Oz Side Vodka

$1.95

Extra Caesar

$1.00

Side Of Balsamic Glaze

$1.00

Side Of Ceasar

$1.00

Pizza Kit

$12.99

Quart Vodka Sauce

$14.99

Buffalo Sauce

$1.00

Broccoli

$7.99

Small Side Veggies

$7.99

Jr. Chocolate Fudge Cake

$10.00

Cannoli Zepploe

$2.25

Rainbow Cake

$10.00

Fountain Soda

$2.75

16.9 Water

$1.99

Glass Coke Bottle

$2.50

Can Soda

$1.99

2 LITER SODA

$3.99

Boylan Glass Soda

$2.75

20 Ounce Seltser Bottle

$2.75

4 Pack Boylan

$10.00

6 Pack Oldfashion Coke

$12.00

Seltser From Fountain

$1.75

Manhattan Special

$2.75

Coffee

$3.50

Hot Tea

$2.50

Cappuccino

$5.95

Quick Choc Milk

$2.99

Pitcher Of Soda

$13.99

Espresso

$4.99

Large Pelligrino

$5.99

Celcius Drink

$2.99

Double Espresso

$9.00

Snapple

$2.50

Gateraide

$2.50

Saratoga Sparkling Water

$5.99

Can Seltser

$1.99

Ice Tea Bottle San Benedetto

$1.99

Beverage

Vegan

VEGAN 18 Neapolitan

$22.99

VEGAN 14 Neopolitan

$19.99

VEGAN Sicilian

$24.99

VEGAN DETROIT

$22.99

VEGAN GLUTEN FREE Detroit

$16.99

VEGAN Gluten Free Personal

$16.99

Vegan Grandma

$27.99

18 Vegan 4 Veggie Toppings

$32.99

14 4 Toppings

$27.99

Single Garlic Knot

$0.75

3oz Sauce

$1.00

Can Soda

$1.99

1 Boylan Glass

$2.75

4 Pack Boylan

$10.00

16.9 Water

$1.99

Glass Coke Bottle

$2.50

Cake

$6.99

2 LITER SODA

$3.99

20 Ounce Seltser Bottle

$2.75

Manhattan Special

$2.75

Quick Choc Milk

$2.99

Fountain Soda

$2.75

Can Seltser

$1.99

Ice Tea Bottle San Benedetto

$1.99

12 Doz Garlic Knots

$3.50

1 Dozen Knots

$7.00

Speed Screen